Diagram showing a central star with rays connected by dashed and solid lines to smaller star points.

Operating compared with the alternatives

Choosing a PSA, or deciding whether you need one at all? This page links to every comparison we have written, grouped by the kind of tool you are coming from.

We're one of the products compared. Each page takes competitor facts from the vendor's own pages and says when we checked them.

Four kinds of tools you will compare

Enterprise PSA tools

Kantata, Certinia, BigTime and the likes cover a lot of ground. These platforms were founded in the 2000s and 2010s and were designed with yesterday's consulting organisation in mind. They're more expensive than modern platforms.

All-in-one agency tools

Productive, Scoro and similar all-in-one platforms bundle CRM and project management with time and billing. You get one product, but less choice over the tools your teams work in.

Time trackers and scheduling tools

Harvest, Clockify, and Float are great generic tools for time tracking and resourcing. However, these are not made specifically for agencies and consulting firms. You'll end up running parts of your processes in spreadsheets.

ERP-adjacent PSA tools

ERP vendors often sell a PSA module on the side. These are e.g. Workday PSA, NetSuite SuiteProjects Pro, and Deltek Workbook. They're often behind in their UX, as they're not the core product the company is focused on selling and developing.

What Operating does, and what it leaves to other tools

Operating is the operations layer of a services firm: people, projects, time and money. Selling stays in your CRM, delivery work stays in the project management or issue tracking tool your teams already use, and invoices flow to your accounting platform. Operating can integrate to those.

We think AI-native firms will run their client projects in AI-native work management tools such as Linear or Legora, and they will need operations data of the same quality underneath. All-in-one agency suites put delivery and operations into one product, and you end up compromising on one of them.

Selling

Stays in you CRM like HubSpot, Salesforce or Pipedrive. Deals become tentative projects in Operating.

Delivery work

Stays in Linear, Jira, Asana or the AI-native tool your team works in.

Accounting

Stays in Xero, QuickBooks Online, NetSuite or other ERP. Invoices go out from Operating and payment status comes back.

Operations

Runs in Operating: staffing, capacity, timesheets, budgets, invoicing and revenue recognition.

AI assistants

Claude, ChatGPT and other MCP-capable assistants get full access to Operating through its MCP server. Compare PSA tools with MCP

Firms that chose Operating

How Eliza, a fast growing AI-native consulting firm runs their delivery on Operating

Read the story

How Modus Create, a 350-person engineering firm, replaced a scattered set of systems

Read the story

How Columbia Road moved 150+ people off Harvest Forecast and spreadsheets

Read the story

Two young men sitting at a table in a sunlit room with large windows and indoor plants, smiling and engaged in conversation or work.

Every comparison in one place

Head to head pages compare Operating with one tool. Alternatives pages compare several tools.

Enterprise PSA tools

All-in-one agency tools

Time trackers and scheduling tools

ERP-adjacent PSA tools

Before you choose

Frequently
Asked Questions

What are the alternatives to Operating?

The PSA tools most often compared with Operating are Kantata, Certinia, NetSuite SuiteProjects Pro, BigTime, Scoro, Productive and Ruddr. Firms coming from a single-purpose tool usually compare Harvest, Float or Clockify against a PSA. Each has its own page above.

How is Operating different from enterprise PSA software like Kantata or Certinia?

Operating covers resource planning, time tracking, budgets, invoicing and revenue recognition for firms of 30 to 10,000 people, and connects to your CRM and accounting system instead of replacing them. Enterprise suites cover more ground and usually need more setup and a dedicated admin.

Is Operating an alternative to Harvest and Harvest Forecast?

Yes. Operating replaces both, and it can also keep Harvest for time tracking through a native integration while it handles planning, forecasting and margins.

Do I need a PSA if my ERP has a project module?

An ERP project module records what happened. A PSA plans who works on what next and forecasts revenue and utilization from that plan. Many firms run both, with the PSA sending invoices and revenue to the ERP.

Can AI assistants like Claude and ChatGPT work with Operating's data?

Yes. Operating's MCP server gives Claude, ChatGPT and other MCP-capable assistants full access to the product, within the user's own permissions. Each tool can be switched on or off per user and the permissions Operating uses also apply to individual users' MCP use.

How can AI help our consulting firm automate our work?

You can create agentic workflow that run based on triggers or on a certain cadence. E.g. you could monitor a Google Drive folder for new SoWs, and automatically add a project plan to Operating based on that, or you can run a weekly project margin health check to flag any concerns. You can build these automations directly inside Claude or ChatGPT.

How much does Operating cost compared with other PSA tools?

Operating costs $15 to $23 per person per month on monthly billing, less on annual billing, and every plan includes data migration, training and support. The PSA pricing comparison lists 24 tools at the plan you would actually need.

How long does it take to switch to Operating?

We migrate customers as fast as in a week, when you're coming from a smaller point solution like Harvest time tracking. For larger firms migrating from legacy tools, you want to reserve some time for change management. We're still talking about getting live in weeks with the help of our onboarding team.

How do you keep these comparisons fair and current?

We make one of the products compared, so each page takes competitor facts from the vendor's own pages and states the date we checked them. Each page also says where the other tool is the better choice.

Get started

Talk with Lauri,
our CEO